top of page

No Probable Cause, No Entry: Iowa Court's Bold Stand for Renters

In a recent development, an Iowa court has made a significant ruling regarding the constitutionality of arbitrary rental property inspections, reported by Sioux City Journal. This decision reaffirms the importance of constitutional protections for renters and property owners alike, emphasizing that being a tenant should not diminish one's rights.

So, picture this: It all started back in 2021 when Orange City, Iowa, decided to play inspector by passing an ordinance. What did this ordinance say, you ask? Well, it basically required folks who owned rental properties to register them with the city and, get this, submit to inspections every five years. No evidence of wrongdoing, no probable cause – nada. They even threw in a little clause that allowed inspectors to pull an administrative search warrant if they weren't welcomed with open arms.

Naturally, this didn't sit well with landlords and tenants alike. Imagine the audacity of the government just waltzing into your private property whenever they pleased! That's where our trusty Constitution is supposed to come in. You see, the Fourth Amendment and state constitutions make it crystal clear that a warrant for a search must be based on probable cause – not some rubber-stamped, administrative nonsense.

Back in June 2021, the Des Moines Register ran a story about Bryan Singer and Erika Nordyke, Orange City residents who weren't having any of it. They took the city to court, saying these inspections were trampling all over their Iowa Constitutional rights.

Now, let's fast forward to the courtroom. Iowa District Judge Jeffrey A. Neary took center stage, and boy, did he have some strong words. He pointed out that the ordinance was a flimsy piece of work – no specifics, standards, or procedures for those administrative search warrants. Tenants got no heads-up about the process, leaving them powerless to challenge it. And did I mention the broad scope of those warrants? They practically allowed for a full-blown police parade through your living room.

In a nutshell, the court declared the inspection program a direct violation of your search-and-seizure rights. It was like a sneak attack on the Fourth Amendment and Iowa Constitution's Article I, Section 8.

Judge Neary didn't mince words. In his ruling, Judge Neary concluded that more safeguards and protective measures were needed. He permanently prohibited the city from seeking administrative warrants for inspections, asserting that such measures were currently lacking in Iowa's inspection process.

This isn't just about Orange City; it's about all of Iowa. This ruling extends its implications beyond Orange City. The Iowa League of Cities has advocated for rental registration and inspection programs across the state. In light of this decision, all such programs must now demonstrate their compliance with protections against unreasonable searches and seizures to avoid potential constitutional challenges.

Moreover, the National Apartment Association, a trade group, has raised concerns about rental housing inspection laws, highlighting financial burdens on property owners, infringements on personal privacy rights, and unequal treatment of apartment housing compared to other property types. These laws may face challenges based on state constitutions and the Fourth Amendment.

This case serves as a vital reminder that constitutional protections are not merely bureaucratic hurdles for government officials. They serve as essential safeguards against the potential misuse of power by officials who might exploit their authority. As a result of this ruling, Orange City rental inspectors are now required to establish probable cause before entering people's homes, reducing the potential harm they can inflict, regardless of their motivations.

In conclusion, the Iowa court's decision is a significant step in upholding the constitutional rights of renters and property owners, emphasizing that these rights are not contingent on ownership and should be protected for all individuals equally.

What do you think of the ruling and outcome?

Doni Anthony (Doni The Don)

Introducing Doni Anthony (Doni The Don), Founder of Liberty Or Else and a passionate advocate for individual liberties and natural human rights.

Join her engaging podcast, subscribe to her blog, and catch her inspiring speeches at public events. Support her work on Cash App or Venmo. Follow Doni on Facebook and Twitter for valuable insights and updates. #LibertyOrElse


bottom of page